PDF Expert Review 2017: Is It the Fastest PDF Editor for Mac?
Review of: PDF Expert Version 2.2.9 (412)
Use: Read, annotate and edit PDFs
Quickly annotate and edit PDFs
One-time payment of $59.99 USD
Ease of Use
Easy to use with intuitive tools
Knowledge base, contact via online form
What I like:
- This app is fast, even with huge PDF files.
- The annotation and editing tools are easy to use.
- Tabbed interface makes it easy to switch between PDFs.
- It's a good choice for reading PDFs too.
What I dislike:
- The program lacks OCR.
- Signing using the trackpad is messy.
Summary: Readdle PDF Expert is a fast and intuitive PDF editor for Mac and iOS. While you are reading a PDF, an extensive set of annotation tools allow you to highlight, take notes, and doodle. A set of editing tools allow you to make corrections to the text of a PDF, as well as change or adjust images.
Is PDF Expert the app for you? If you need basic markup and editing features, and you value speed and ease of use, then definitely! This is one quick and easy app.
But if you're looking for editing power, the feature set is more limited than the alternatives — despite the word "Expert" in the name. While the tools are easy to use, they are also a little less capable, and the app is not able to provide optical character recognition (OCR) on scanned documents. Adobe Acrobat Pro or PDFelement will better meet your needs.
Why Should You Trust Me?
My name is Adrian Try. I've been using computers since 1988 and Macs full time since 2009. In my quest to go paperless, I've created thousands of PDFs from the stacks of paperwork that used to fill my office. I also use PDF files extensively for ebooks, user manuals and reference.
On my paperless journey I've used a range of scanners and apps to create and manage my PDF collection, both on Mac and iOS. Most days I need to read or search for information in a PDF, and most days I create a few more to throw on the pile. I hadn't tried Readdle PDF Expert, so I downloaded the trial version and put it through its paces, testing every feature the app offers.
What did I discover? The content in the summary box above will give you a good idea of my findings and conclusions. Read on for the ins and outs of everything I liked and disliked about the app.
What Is PDF Expert?
PDF Expert is a fast and intuitive PDF editor. Besides allowing you to read PDF content, it enables you to add your own notes and highlights, and even change the text and images within a PDF file. The app is also a convenient way of filling in and signing PDF forms.
Speed and simplicity are its strength. How fast is PDF Expert? It's incredibly responsive. Other reviewers agree:
- "Readdle managed to add this functionality and still run circles around the performance of Preview, which has always been notoriously slow to launch or open files. By comparison, PDF Expert 2 is greased lightning. It's so fast, I've made it my default application for all PDF files." (J.R. Bookwalter, MacWorld)
- "This year I've had to use some particularly large PDFs – documents that are almost 1000 pages. Preview would load them, but it wasn't uncommon for Preview to hang for a few moments if I scrolled through them quickly (for reference I'm using a mid-2012 MacBook Air with a 2GHz Intel Core i7 and 8GB of memory). So to test PDF Expert I loaded 7 of the largest PDFs I had on hand, which in total, came to just under 5,000 pages and around 140MB. No matter what I did, whether it was scrolling rapidly, zooming in to a very a large size, quickly switching tabs, I couldn't detect any lag or hangs. PDF Expert definitely felt a lot more resilient than Preview." (Graham Spencer, MacStories)
The app is a nice way to read PDFs. It has day, night and sepia modes for more comfortable reading, fast search, and handy bookmarks. It was voted "App of the Year" in the Mac App Store in 2015.
Is It Free?
No, PDF Expert is not free, though it does come with a trial version so you can fully evaluate it before parting with your cash. It costs $59.99, giving you a license for three Macs. Students and professors can apply for an educational discount.
Is It Safe?
Yes, it is safe to use. I ran and installed PDF Expert on my macOS Sierra based MacBook Air. A scan using Bitdefender found no viruses or malicious code.
Several Mac App Store reviews complain of frequent crashing. That's not my experience. In face, I didn't have any problems with the app whatsoever.
PDF Expert for iPad and iPhone
PDF Expert is also available for iOS. It's a $9.99 universal app that works on both iPhone and iPad, and supports Apple Pencil. Signatures are synced across all of your devices.
PDF Expert for Windows
PDF Expert: What's In It For You?
Since PDF Expert is all about editing PDF documents, I'll cover its features by in the following five sections, first exploring what the app offers, then sharing my personal take.
1. Annotate Your PDF Documents
Whether I'm studying or editing, I prefer to have a pen in my hand. That simple act moves me from passively taking in information to directly interacting with it, evaluating it, digesting it. The app allows you to do the same with PDF documents.
Cult of Mac's George Tinari found PDF Expert's annotation and markup features easy to use, and I agree. "Working with a file is ridiculously straightforward. After opening a PDF, you'll see all the tools available nicely lined up at the top, plus document view, zoom and search functions. From left to right, you can highlight, underline and strikeout text, use a pen, eraser, text or shapes, or add a note, stamp, signature or make a selection. Annotations and bookmarks conveniently save in the left side to improve organization."
To test PDF Expert's annotation features, I downloaded a PDF user manual. There are two options at the centre of the top bar of the app: Annotate and Edit. Make sure Annotate is selected.
The first icon is the highlighter tool, which allows you to change color very easily. Just select the text to highlight.
The pen, text, shapes, note and stamps tools are similarly easy to use.
When J.R. Bookwalter reviewed the app for MacWorld, he found the stamps tool the biggest improvement: "Editing may be the star of PDF Expert 2, but there are welcome improvements to the existing annotation lineup as well. The biggest is Stamps, which allow users to markup documents using virtual imprints; a wide variety are included, but you can also create your own. The crop tool also comes in handy, offering the option to trim just the current page, or an entire document at once."
My personal take:
PDF Expert's annotation features take it from being just a PDF reader to a tool for actively working with information. That's great for study, effective for marking assignments submitted as PDFs, and useful for editors.
2. Edit Your PDF Documents
PDF editing is a new feature for PDF Expert version 2. MacWorld's J.R. Bookwalter found it quick and easy, but lacking in features. "By far the most impressive new features are the ability to edit text and images. Whether fixing a last-minute typo or swapping out a company logo, PE2's slick user interface makes it a snap, although the tools are fairly basic. I successfully replaced one image from a magazine article, but couldn't match the 20-degree angle of the original; the rotate tools only work 45 degrees at a time."
To test the app's editing ability, I selected Edit at the top of our PDF user manual. Four new options appeared: Text, Image, Link and Redact.
I selected Text and some controls appeared on the right of the screen. When clicking on text in the document, the font settings changed to match the text.
9to5Mac's Jordan Kahn appreciated this feature: "The editor in version 2.2 gets a big upgrade with the ability to ‘automatically detect the font, size, and opacity of the original text so you can edit PDFs like regular text documents.'" When I added additional text, the font matched perfectly. I was able to bold the text and change its color, though the usual command-B shortcut key didn't work.
Next I tried the Image tool. Not all images are recognized as images. With those that are, a black border is placed around the image when hovering the mouse over it.
Clicking the image places a dotted blue border around the image, with resize handles.
The image can now be resized and moved around the document. Guides appear to help you line up the image with the surrounding text, however text does not wrap around the image when it overlaps. Images can also be cut, copied and pasted.
New images can be inserted by clicking or dragging the mouse, and selecting the required image file.
Finally I tested the Link tool. It's useful for adding hyperlinks to the web, or internal links to other sections of the PDF. Click on the tool, then select the text you want to convert to a link.
For a web link, select "to Web" then enter the URL.
As Cult of Mac's George Tinari discovered, editing in PDF Expert is fast, even for long documents: "I'm thoroughly pleased by how fast PDF Expert is even when handling long or graphically intense documents. It's also hard to beat the ease of use."
My personal take:
If your main goal for purchasing this program is the complex editing of PDF documents, you may be better served with another app. But for basic editing of text and images, you won't find an easier-to-use PDF editor.
3. Fill In & Sign PDF Forms
More and more business forms are available as PDFs. It's very convenient being able to fill in the form electronically, without having to print it out and fill it in manually.
To test PDF Expert's form filling features, I downloaded an online form for applying for Australian citizenship. I opened the file, and ensured that neither Annotate or Edit were selected at the top of the form.
Filling in the form was easy. Clicking on a checkbox added a check. Clicking on a text field allowed me to enter text.
To sign the form, I selected Annotate then clicked the My Signatures tool.
I can add a signature to PDF Expert via the keyboard, signing on the trackpad, or from an image of my signature.
A text signature is fine in some situations. I used one a few years ago when applying for a finance option for a guitar. Using the trackpad was a little messy. I got the best result by using a thin (0.5 pt) line, and looking at the trackpad rather than the screen when I signed with my finger.
It sounds like Cult of Mac's George Tinari had a similar experience. "I wasn't a fan of how trackpad signatures recognized my finger. My signature ended up pretty sloppy every time."
The nicest option is to use an image of your signature. You'll need to scan and crop the image before adding it to PDF Expert.
Whichever method you use to add your signature, drag it to the appropriate place on your form. From there, you can tweak the color and line thickness.
My personal take:
Filling in a form with PDF Expert was fast and easy, though to be honest using the Mac's Preview app is almost as effective.
4. Reorder & Delete Pages
Besides editing the text on a page, the app allows you to make larger scale changes to your document, including reordering and deleting pages. This is accomplished using Page Thumbnails, which is the second icon on the top bar.
Options appear for adding a page, appending a file, copying (and pasting) a page, rotating a page, and deleting a page. There are also options for sharing and extracting a single page. To reorder pages, simply drag and drop.
Pages can be deleted either from the icon at the top of the screen, or by right-clicking on a page.
MacStories's Graham Spencer was impressed with PDF Expert's ability to manipulate pages, especially when compared with Apple's Preview. "Preview can merge PDF documents, delete pages, move pages around, extract pages, and so on. But I find that a lot of the time it can be fiddly and feel as though they were features tacked on. That is not the case with PDF Expert for Mac, where it is far simpler to do these tasks."
My personal take:
Rearranging and deleting pages from a PDF is simple with PDF Expert. If you do that often, you may find that feature alone justifies the price of admission.
5. Redact Personal Information
When sharing PDFs that contain personal or sensitive information, it is often necessary to redact some of the content in the file. In PDF Expert, this is done using the Redact editing tool. I tried this on our PDF user manual. PDF Expert's tabbed interface made switching back to this document easy.
First click Edit, then Redact. You can redact by erasing text, or blacking it out. I chose the Blackout option.
After that, it's just a matter of selecting the text you want to redact.
My personal take:
Redaction is an important and frequent task in some professions. PDF Expert allows you to redact sensitive information without fuss.
Reasons Behind My Reviews and Ratings
What PDF Expert does, it does very well. It's just that the range of features is a little narrower than most of its competitors. If the app does everything you need, its ease of use will make the purchase worthwhile. If you regularly create and OCR PDFs, you'll need to look elsewhere.
This Mac PDF editor app is somewhat cheaper than the alternatives, but the price gap is closer than in previous versions. As J.R. Bookwalter from MacWorld points out, "While PDF Expert 2 is more affordable than competitors like Adobe Acrobat DC or PDFpen, the price also increased accordingly; owners of the first version (originally $20) receive the update free of charge."
Ease of Use: 5/5
PDF Expert is one of the most intuitive apps I have used. Click Annotate, and all of the tools you need are there. Click Edit, and you can change text and add images. If you're after a fast, easy-to-use PDF editor, add the app to your shopping list.
Readdle provides a comprehensive knowledge base for their products, and support can be contacted via a form on their website. While phone and chat support are not offered, the app is very intuitive, so that level of support is unlikely to be needed.
Alternatives to PDF Expert
Adobe Acrobat Pro DC: Adobe Acrobat Pro was the first app for reading and editing PDF documents, and is still one of the best options. However, it is quite expensive. An annual subscription costs $179.88. Read our Acrobat review here.
ABBYY FineReader: ABBYY FineReader is a well-respected app that shares many features with Acrobat. It, too, comes with a high price tag, though not a subscription.
Wondershare PDFelement: PDFelement is another affordable PDF editor, costing $59.95 (Standard) or $99.95 (Professional). Read our PDFelement review.
Apple Preview: The Mac's Preview app allows you to not only view PDF documents, but mark them up as well. The Markup toolbar includes icons for sketching, drawing, adding shapes, typing text, adding signatures, and adding pop-up notes. This functionality will be expanded in High Sierra.
PDF is a common file type, and the closest thing you'll find to paper on your computer. In these days when many companies are going paperless, it's more common than ever. PDF Expert promises to help you read, markup and edit those documents quickly and easily.
PDF editors can be expensive and difficult to use. Some programs include so many features that you need to do a course to learn how to use them effectively. PDF Expert shares many of the same features, but not the complexity. It makes editing PDFs simple.
Do you value speed and ease-of-use over advanced features? Then PDF Expert is for you. It's the fastest and easiest to use PDF editor I've used.