Corel AfterShot Pro 3 Review: Can It Compete As A Pro RAW Editor?

Use: RAW Image Editing

Effectiveness

Most tools are excellent, but localized edits need work

Price

Extremely affordable and provides good value for money

Ease of Use

Overall easy to use with a few small UI issues

Support

Excellent support from Corel, but limited within the program

What I like:

  • Compact Single-Screen Workflow
  • Fast Batch Editing
  • Widescreen UI Design
  • No Catalog Imports Required

What I dislike:

  • No In-Program Tutorial
  • Small UI Issues
  • Localized Editing Process Needs Work
  • Preset Packs Are Expensive

Summary: Corel AfterShot Pro 3 is an excellent RAW image editor that provides a fast, compact workflow. It has a solid library management tools, excellent developing options and a flexible plugin/add-on system.

The software is aimed at professional photographers, but may not be quite ready to fulfill that role properly thanks to certain issues with the way it handles localized editing. For those who are already using a standalone editor such as Photoshop or PaintShop Pro in their workflow, this is a minor issue that shouldn't prevent you from making good use of AfterShot Pro's compact single-screen workflow and fast batch editing.

Why You Should Trust Me?

Hi, my name is Thomas Boldt, and I've been working with image editing software for over 15 years. I trained as a graphic designer while teaching myself photography at the same time, eventually working as a product photographer shooting everything from jewelry to artistic furniture.

Over the course of my photographic practice, I've experimented with a number of different workflows and image editors, giving me a wide range of insight into just what can be expected from a top-notch program. My training as a graphic designer also included courses on user interface design, which helps me sort the good programs from the bad.

Disclaimer: Corel provided me with no compensation or free software in exchange for this review, nor have they had any kind of editorial review or input on the content.

What Is Corel AfterShot Pro?

Corel AfterShot Pro 3 is a complete RAW editing workflow program available for Windows, Mac, and Linux, allowing you to develop, edit and export your RAW images. It is aimed at the professional market, as you might guess from the name, but it is still struggling to challenge Adobe Lightroom as the most commonly-used RAW editor.

Is Corel AfterShot Pro Free?

No, AfterShot Pro 3 is not free software, but there is an unlimited 30-day free trial available from the Corel website. After that time is expired, you can purchase the full version of the software for a very affordable $79.99, although as of this writing Corel is featuring a 30% off sale, bringing the price down to just $54.99. This makes it one of the most affordable standalone RAW editors on the market by a significant margin.

​Corel AfterShot Pro 3 Tutorials

Many of the features of AfterShot pro 3 will be familiar to users of other RAW editing programs, but in case you need a little bit of guidance, there is some tutorial information available online. Note: As of this writing, Amazon only has one book available on AfterShot Pro, and it was published back in 2012 about one of the earlier versions.

Corel AfterShot Pro vs. Adobe Lightroom

AfterShot Pro is Corel's direct challenge to Adobe Lightroom's dominance of the RAW editing market, and they aren't ashamed to admit it. Front and center on the AfterShot Pro website is a claim that the latest version handles batch editing up to 4 times faster than Lightroom, and you can read the data sheet they published here.

One of the most interesting differences between Lightroom and AfterShot Pro is the way they render the same RAW images. Lightroom uses the Adobe Camera RAW (ACR) algorithm to render images, which often come out with narrower tonal ranges and slightly washed out colors. AfterShot Pro uses its own proprietary algorithm to render RAW images, and it almost always produces better results than ACR. Resource Magazine compiled an excellent comparison between Lightroom, Capture One and AfterShot Pro which is worth a look.

While seems to be faster, there are still some issues that Corel will have to overcome to properly challenge Lightroom. Speedy batching is great, but AfterShot's clumsy localized editing has a long way to go to catch up to Lightroom's excellent local options. If you're not interested in doing localized edits, though, AfterShot's compact one-screen workflow and better initial rendering might be able to convince you to switch programs. The best way to find out is to read this review and then test it for yourself!

A Closer Look at Corel AfterShot Pro 3

AfterShot Pro 3 is a large program, with a number of different features that we don't have time or space to go into. Instead, we'll look at the most common uses of the program, as well as anything that makes it stand out from the other RAW editors on the market.

Please also note that the screenshots below are taken from the Windows version, so if you're using AfterShot Pro for Mac or Linux the interface will look slightly different.

General Interface & Workflow

Corel managed the download and installation process very carefully, so I was a bit surprised to be dropped into the deep end when it came to actually using the software. As you can see below, the interface is a bit busy and there is no introduction or tutorial splash screen to provide any guidance. You can visit the AfterShot Pro learning center through the Help menu, though, and their videos were able to provide some of the basic information about using the program. It's worth noting that the main introduction video appears to be slightly out of date at the time of this writing, showing some minor UI changes compared to the version I'm using.

​Once you start to get used to the interface, you can see that it's actually rather well-designed in a style that takes advantage of the extra horizontal width of widescreen monitors. Instead of placing the filmstrip navigation below the main working window, it runs vertically down the left side of the preview window. This means that you'll get larger previews of your full-size images without having to constantly show or hide aspects of the interface (although you still can, if you want to).

Another interesting choice is that Corel has decided to buck the trend of following Lightroom's module layout system, instead choosing to keep every tool and feature in a single main interface. This is part of the reason that the UI seems a bit cluttered at first, but it definitely has its advantages when it comes to speed and consistency.

The aspect of the UI that I found most confusing initially was the vertical text navigation at the extreme edges of the window. On the left, they allow you to navigate between Library and File System views of your images, while on the right you can navigate through the different editing types: Standard, Color, Tone, Detail. You can also quickly download new camera profiles to match your specific camera equipment, if they're recent enough not to be included in the default installation, apply watermarks, or work with additional plugins. The vertical text navigation is a bit difficult to read at first, but once you get used to it, you realize it conserves a lot of screen space without compromising usability too much.

Library Management

​One of the biggest workflow advantages to AfterShot Pro 3 is that you don't have to maintain a catalog of imported photos - instead, you can choose to work directly with your existing folder structure. Since I already organize all my photos in folders by date, this is extremely helpful to me and saves some importing time. You can create image catalogs if you prefer, but it's generally faster not to unless your folder structure is a mess (we've all been there at one point). The main advantage of using catalogs is that you can search and sort your library by metadata instead of just basic folder structure, but the trade-off is the time it takes to import.

Otherwise, the library management tools are quite excellent, and will be immediately familiar to anyone who has worked with Lightroom in the past. Color tagging, star ratings and pick/reject flags are all available to help you sort through larger collections at once, whether you're using catalogs or folders. The only thing that feels slightly inconsistent is that the metadata editor is included as a tab on the right navigation among the editing controls, when it might be better off on the left navigation with the library tools.

Basic Editing

Most of the editing features found in AfterShot Pro 3 are excellent. They are fairly standard options by this point, but the adjustments are applied quickly. Automatic camera/lens correction worked smoothly and flawlessly without any help from me, which is a nice change compared to some of the other RAW editors I have reviewed recently.

There are two main automatic adjustment settings in AfterShot Pro, AutoLevel and Perfectly Clear. AutoLevel adjusts the tones of your image to make a certain percentage of the pixels pure black and a certain percentage pure white. By default the settings are far too strong, which gives an incredibly exaggerated contrast effect as you can see below. Of course, you probably won't want to use automatic adjustments, but it would be nice to have a reliable option to do so.

The AutoLevel option with default settings. I don't think anyone would consider this to be a properly edited image, although it does highlight how dirty this lens had gotten without me noticing.

​Perfectly Clear is included as part of a licensing deal with Athentech, which also provided the Perfectly Clear Noise Removal tool found in the Detail tab. In theory, it optimizes lighting without clipping any shadow or highlight pixels, removes tints and adds a bit of sharpening/contrast. It does a better job with this tricky image, but still not quite right.

The Perfectly Clear option on the same photo. Not quite as aggressive as the AutoLevel option, but still way too strong.

​I decided to give it a simpler image to work from to see how well it would handle it, and the final results were much better.

Original image, left. Edited with 'Perfectly Clear' on the right. A much more satisfactory result with no bizarrely excessive contrast.

​While experimenting with the editing process, I encountered a few strange UI quirks. There is no way to quickly reset a single edit - to return the highlight range to its default setting of 25, for example, a setting you might forget. You have to either remember the default or reset every setting at once, which hardly makes for a streamlined workflow. Using the Undo command might seem the easiest way to overcome this, but I found that when using it with the Straighten edit, it actually took 2 or 3 repetitions of the command to get back to zero. This may be due to how the sliders are programmed, I'm not entirely sure, but it's a bit irritating.

You can also use the scroll wheel on your mouse to scroll through the whole editing panel on the right, but as soon as your cursor crosses over a slider, AfterShot then applies your scrolling action to the slider setting instead of the panel. This makes it a little too easy to accidentally adjust settings without meaning to.

Layer Editing

If you want to dig deeper into more localized edits, you'll be using the layer manager to add, edit and delete adjustment layers. Accessed from the top toolbar, it allows you to create two types of layers: an adjustment layer, which allows you to create localized versions of any of the main editing options, and a heal/clone layer, which allows you to duplicate sections of an image. You can use various shapes to define the affected regions (the Corel version of masking), or you can use a freehand brush.

​For some completely inexplicable reason, you cannot use the brush tool to define a region on a heal/clone layer. Maybe I'm just conditioned from working with Photoshop, but I found this to be quite frustrating. Good cloning isn't always the easiest thing to do, but it's much more difficult when you're limited to working with clumsy preset shapes.

Even when you're working with a more typical adjustment layer, the default settings are slightly strange. Show Strokes is initially turned off, which makes it essentially impossible to tell exactly where you're brushing at first glance. There's also no option to create a gradient on adjustment layers, unless you're willing and able to paint one yourself using feathered brushes.

This area of the program has some great potential, but it definitely needs a little more polishing before it's ready to meet the standards set by the rest of the available features.

Preset Packs

One of the more unique features of the program is the ability to download and install various add-ons in the form of camera profiles, plugins and presets from within the interface itself using the Get More tab. The camera profiles themselves are all free, and almost all of the available plugins are free as well.

​The download and installation process was extremely fast, although it does require restarting the application to enable the new download. It might also be nice to have a little bit of a description to see what exactly 'zChannelMixer64' does before downloading it, although some of them are a bit more obvious than others.

​The preset packs, which from what I can see are mostly glorified Instagram filters, are astonishingly expensive at $4.99 or more per pack. That may not seem like much, but buying all of the preset packs would wind up actually being more expensive than the initial purchase price of the software itself. This makes me think that Corel is counting on them to act as a continuing revenue stream, although I'm not sure who they think the target market is.

​The Reasons Behind My Ratings

Effectiveness: 4/5

Overall, AfterShot Pro 3 has excellent library organization and editing tools. The only thing that prevents me from giving it a 5 star rating is the clumsy localized editing tools, which definitely need some more polishing before they are ready to match the quality of the program's other features.

Price: 5/5

AfterShot Pro 3 is one of the most affordable RAW image editors available today, and may even be the cheapest available. It provides a great balance of features considering its incredibly low price point, although it is only available as a standalone program which will require additional purchases in order to stay up to date with the latest version.

Ease of Use: 4.5/5

Once you get used to the interface, AfterShot Pro 3 is generally quite easy to use. Again, the localized editing tools become something of a frustration, but that's the only element that prevents me from giving it a 5-star rating. Otherwise, the user interface is well-designed, compact and customizable, allowing you to use it the way that works best for you.

Support: 4/5

Corel has provided excellent tutorial support for their website, although there is an almost complete lack of support from any third party provider such as Lynda.com and no books available on Amazon. I didn't run into a single bug while using the software during my testing, but if I had, it would have been relatively easy to get in touch with their support staff thanks to the online support portal.

AfterShot Pro Alternatives

Adobe Lightroom

Lightroom is one of the most popular RAW editors on the market, and with good reason. It's a solid program that is well-designed with a thoroughly tested user interface. Adobe Camera RAW, the algorithm that processes RAW image data, isn't quite as nuanced as those found in other programs, but Adobe makes up for it with the rest of the program's ease of use. Available for Windows and Mac as part of the Adobe Creative Cloud subscription service in a package with Photoshop for $9.99 USD per month. Read our Lightroom review here.

Phase One Capture One Pro

Capture One Pro is arguably the most powerful and accurate RAW image editor out there. Aimed directly at the high-end professional market, it has excellent RAW rendering features, although it is definitely not the easiest program to learn. If you're willing to put the time into learning it, however, it's hard to beat in terms of technical quality. Available for Windows and Mac either as a standalone program for $299 USD or as a monthly subscription for $20.

DxO OpticsPro

OpticsPro is an excellent standalone editor, although it lacks many of the additional features found in AfterShot Pro such as library management. Instead, it focuses on extremely easy automatic corrections thanks to DxO's massive library of lens testing data that allows it to perfectly correct optical distortions. It also features an industry-leading noise cancellation algorithm in its ELITE edition. Available for Windows and Mac in two versions, Standard for $129 USD or ELITE for $199.

Conclusion

Corel AfterShot Pro 3 is an excellent program that is almost ready to make a takeover of the RAW editing market. It has great RAW rendering capabilities and solid non-destructive editing tools, although its layer-based editing definitely needs more work on the usability side of things. If you're already a Lightroom user, it's definitely worth a look, especially if you do a lot of batch editing as part of your existing practice. If you're working on a higher-end professional level, it probably won't be able to convince you to change your software allegiance, but it's definitely one to keep an eye on for future releases.

Thomas Boldt
 

I've been actively writing for the web on a range of subjects for almost a decade, but I became a techie as soon as I got to use a computer for the first time at age 6. Ever since then I've been fascinated by technology of all kinds, from building my own computers to experimenting with hardware maker projects and software that powers them. I've seen the good side of software and the bad, and I'm here to share the benefit of that experience with you.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 2 comments